Appraise the difference between situational leadership versus traits approach
1. Critically appraise the difference between situational leadership versus traits approach or skills and style approaches to leadership, providing examples of strengths and weaknesses of each approach using at least one example to embellish your answer
2. Discuss how leaders can facilitate and promote creativity and innovation in individuals, teams or organizations. Use appropriate theory and examples to support your answer.
3. Critically discuss how specific leadership contexts, such as leadership in the context of health care, religious organizations, business, third-sector, etc., might shape the leadership practices, processes or models using at least one exemplary case to support your arguments.
4. Critically discuss how diversity markers such as gender, ethnicity/race, religion, sexuality so on affect leadership. Please concentrate on one of these diversity markers and critically discuss how particular diversity/identity markers shape some leadership aspects. For example, you can ask a question like: "To be a female leader, do you have to emulate masculine leadership?" Please use appropriate examples to support your answer.
Sample Solution
Leadership is a multifaceted concept with various approaches to guide individuals in achieving goals. Here's a breakdown of three prominent approaches:
1. Situational Leadership vs. Traits/Skills Approaches:
-
Situational Leadership: This approach emphasizes adapting leadership style based on the maturity (competence and commitment) of followers. Leaders shift between directive (high directive, low supportive), coaching (high directive, high supportive), supportive (low directive, high supportive), and delegating (low directive, low supportive) styles depending
Full Answer Section
-
- Strengths: Adaptable and effective in diverse situations, promotes follower development.
- Weaknesses: Requires strong self-awareness and follower assessment skills from the leader. Frequent style changes might create confusion.
- Example: A manager leading a newly formed team might initially use a directive style to provide clear guidance and structure. As the team gains experience, the leader can transition to a coaching style to encourage autonomy and growth.
- Traits/Skills Approaches: These approaches focus on inherent qualities (traits) or learned skills believed to be essential for successful leadership.
- Strengths: Provides a framework for identifying and developing potential leaders.
- Weaknesses: Oversimplifies leadership by assuming a one-size-fits-all model. Ignores the importance of situational factors and follower needs.
- Example: A traits approach might identify decisiveness, communication skills, and vision as essential leadership traits. However, this doesn't consider how these traits might need to be applied differently in various contexts.
- Fostering Creativity and Innovation:
- Transformational Leadership: Inspiring and motivating followers to think outside the box, challenging the status quo and embracing change.
- Creating a Psychologically Safe Environment: Encouraging risk-taking, open communication, and acceptance of failure as part of the learning process.
- Providing Resources and Support: Allocating time, budget, and training opportunities for employees to explore new ideas and develop innovative solutions.
- Example:A CEO encourages experimentation by allocating a percentage of the R&D budget for employees to pursue their own innovative projects, fostering a culture of creativity within the organization.
- Contextual Shaping of Leadership:
- Healthcare: Leaders might need to be empathetic, patient, and have strong communication skills to navigate complex ethical considerations and build trust with patients and staff.
- Religious Organizations: Spiritual leaders provide guidance based on religious values and traditions, often focusing on moral development and community building.
- Business: Business leaders require strategic thinking, decision-making skills, and a focus on achieving organizational goals and profitability.
- Third Sector: Nonprofit leaders often prioritize social impact and mission fulfillment, requiring strong advocacy and fundraising skills in resource-constrained environments.
- Example:A hospital administrator might prioritize a collaborative and inclusive leadership style to ensure effective communication and coordination among diverse healthcare professionals.
- Gender and Leadership:
- Do Women Need to be Masculine? Effective female leaders can leverage their strengths in communication, collaboration, and empathy to build strong teams and achieve results.
- Breaking the Mold: Women leaders who embrace their unique styles and strengths can create a more inclusive and diverse leadership landscape.
- Example:Research by Sheryl Sandberg (Lean In) suggests that women can be successful leaders by focusing on collaboration, building strong networks, and advocating for themselves and others.