Assessment-Problem-Question Scenario
Assessment-Problem-Question Scenario
Assessment-Problem-Question Scenario
Order Description
Students are expected to present a very clear and concise answer to the question
Style: Australian Guide to Legal Citation (can be downloaded at http://www.law.unimelb.edu.au/go/aglc).
Assessment Criteria:
This task aims to assess your skill and analytical ability to examine issues involved in the problem scenario with adequate support and acknowledgement. Marks will be awarded based on the following assessment criteria:
• Originality of the work devoid of plagiarism
• A well structured response based on issues raised in the problem scenario
• Understanding and accurate identification of issues
• Application of the relevant legal principles to those issues
• Critical evaluation and efficient use of information
• Concise and logical approach to address relevant aspects
• Adequate substantiation of arguments by referring to relevant legislation and case law
• Clear/coherent demonstration of knowledge and correct written expression
• The degree of persuasion/depth of research evidenced from your argument
• Appropriate referencing and acknowledgement of sources
Relevant Information and Instructions
• Length: 2500 words (excluding footnotes, but footnotes must not include any substantive content. The actual word length of a paper must be stated on the cover sheet).
• Submission: Online via ‘TURNITIN ASSIGNMENT’ on (under ‘Unit Information’ titled ‘Problem Question-Assessment 2- 30%’).
• Assignment must be typed, double spaced and referenced and should conform to the Australian Guide to Legal Citation
• You must not provide a copy of your paper to your classmate/or friend in any circumstances.
Written paper Submission
‘Format
The following requirements as to presentation of written papers must be complied with:
All written assignments must be typed on A4 paper, in 12 point Times New Roman font and must be double-spaced and referenced. You may print on both sides of the paper if your inclinations towards conservation are threatened by the double-spacing requirement.’
International Commercial Law Assessment 2: Problem Question 30 Marks
Problem-Question Scenario:
Assume Aumit and Aron, the two shippers from Mongla entered into two separate contracts with Sam to deliver goods at Paragon port of Grace which is an independent state. Both countries are parties to relevant international conventions regarding carriage of goods by sea and belong to the common legal system. Under a contract with Aumit, Sam agreed to deliver Oxidize Oxfam (OXO) which is considered ‘dangerous goods’ under the International Maritime Dangerous Goods Code. Accordingly, OXO required specific arrangements employed in the ship and careful handling. In particular, OXO was ‘known to increase the risk and intensity of fire in other materials because it tended to yield oxygen when heated.’ During stowage there was evidence that the ‘cargo was placed in a hold directly above the bottom centre fuel tank?a heated tank.’ In the middle of the voyage the crew heated the fuel to abnormally high temperatures which caused OXO to suffer thermal runaway leading to a destructive fire. In a desperate attempt to avert the fire, the master had to scuttle the ship and the cargo was lost during the scuttling operation. Sam now wishes to invoke a strict liability claim against Aumit on various grounds such as he was not aware of the risk inherent in OXO and that a strong wave made the ship volatile and so on. Aumit contests these allegations, arguing that the reason was ‘bad stowage’ and Sam failed to exercise due diligence in making the ship shipworthy.
The contract with Aron required Sam to deliver goods within three months (since the contract concluded) at Paragon. During this three-month period, there was no reason to believe that the hostile relations of Grace with its neighbour will turn into a war. The vessel took an extra 15 days to reach Paragon partly because it had to save human ‘life’. The war, however, formally broke up upon its arrival to Paragon, and the goods were not delivered. Aron argues that the contract has been frustrated due to the delay and the ‘self-motivated initiative’ to secure the property as well. Sam contends that Aron is in breach of safe port obligation.
Answer the following: (12+6+6+6)
1. What are the possible legal issues raised in the above scenario from the perspective of an international contract of carriage of goods by sea? Identify and examine briefly specific laws, international standards and judicial decisions that can be relevant to adequately deal with those issues. (12 Marks)
2. What grounds does Aumit need to establish to have suitable remedies? Substantiate your argument by relying on relevant standards/laws and judicial decisions. (6 Marks)
3. Do you think Aron has a chance of succeeding in a legal battle? Why or why not? Defend your views with special reference to the legal and judicial support. (6 Marks)
4. Evaluate the liabilities of Sam in both cases as raised in the scenario. Advise Sam of his immunities if any. (6 Marks)
Assessment Criteria
This task aims to assess your skill and analytical ability to examine issues involved in the problem scenario with adequate support and acknowledgement. Marks will be awarded based on the following assessment criteria:
• Originality of the work devoid of plagiarism
• A well structured response based on issues raised in the problem scenario
• Understanding and accurate identification of issues
• Application of the relevant legal principles to those issues
• Critical evaluation and efficient use of information
• Concise and logical approach to address relevant aspects
• Adequate substantiation of arguments by referring to relevant legislation and case law
• Clear/coherent demonstration of knowledge and correct written expression
• The degree of persuasion/depth of research evidenced from your argument
• Appropriate referencing and acknowledgement of sources
Relevant Information and Instructions
• Length: 2500 words (excluding footnotes, but footnotes must not include any substantive content. The actual word length of a paper must be stated on the cover sheet).
• Submission: Online via ‘TURNITIN ASSIGNMENT’ on (under ‘Unit Information’ titled ‘Problem Question-Assessment 2- 30%’).
• Assignment must be typed, double spaced and referenced and should conform to the Australian Guide to Legal Citation
• You must not provide a copy of your paper to your classmate/or friend in any circumstances.
Written paper Submission
‘Format
The following requirements as to presentation of written papers must be complied with:
• All written assignments must be typed on A4 paper, in 12 point Times New Roman font and must be double-spaced and referenced. You may print on both sides of the paper if your inclinations towards conservation are threatened by the double-spacing requirement.’