Ethics

Full Answer Section

Actions:

1. Internal Communication: I would initiate a private conversation with the PT Director, expressing my concerns about the misleading advertising and its potential consequences for patient care. I would emphasize the importance of accurate representation and the potential risks of misrepresenting the qualifications of the therapists.
2. Documentation: Document the conversation with the PT Director, including the date, time, and key points discussed.
3. Seek Guidance: If the issue is not resolved internally, I would consider seeking guidance from the state physical therapy board or a professional ethics committee.
4. Patient Education: While addressing the company's advertising practices, I would also prioritize providing accurate information to patients about the qualifications of their therapists.

Case 2: Ethical Dilemma in Resource Allocation

Ethical Considerations:

• Beneficence: Promoting the well-being of patients.
• Justice: Fairness in distribution of resources.
• Autonomy: Respecting patient's choices.

Analysis: Balancing the needs of all patients while accommodating the CEO's father presents a challenge. The limited availability of the NuStep and the potential impact on other patients must be considered.

Actions:

1. Open Communication: I would have an open and honest conversation with the patient about the equipment availability and the impact of his preferred schedule on other patients.
2. Explore Alternatives: I would explore alternative exercise options that could meet the patient's needs and minimize disruption to other patients.
3. Involve the Director: I would involve the director in the decision-making process to seek guidance and support.
4. Prioritize Patient Care: Ultimately, the decision should prioritize the well-being of all patients, ensuring equitable access to resources.

Case 3: Ethical Dilemma in Student Supervision

Ethical Considerations:

• Beneficence: Promoting the well-being of patients.
• Nonmaleficence: Avoiding harm to patients.
• Fidelity: Faithful to commitments made to students and patients.

Analysis: The unexpected emergency creates a challenging situation that requires careful consideration of patient safety and student learning.

Actions:

1. Prioritize Patient Safety: Ensure that patient care is not compromised by the absence of the supervising clinician.
2. Communicate with Colleagues: Inform other therapists about the situation and request their assistance in monitoring the student's performance.
3. Provide Clear Instructions: Before leaving, provide the student with clear instructions and guidance for managing the remaining patients.
4. Maintain Contact: Stay in touch with the facility to address any urgent issues that may arise.
5. Document the Situation: Document the circumstances surrounding the departure and any arrangements made for continued student supervision.

By following these steps, I would strive to minimize disruption to patient care while ensuring the student's continued learning and development.

Sample Solution

Case 1: Ethical Dilemma in Advertising

Ethical Considerations:

• Veracity: Truthfulness and accuracy in advertising.
• Beneficence: Promoting the well-being of patients.
• Fidelity: Faithful to commitments made to patients and colleagues.

Analysis: The company's advertising practices are misleading and potentially harmful to patients. While the company has a positive impact on the community, it is essential to uphold professional standards and ethical principles