How structure of the excerpt help the author make his argument about life in California for Dust Bowl migrants

Sample Solution

The structure of the excerpt plays a crucial role in the author's argument about life in California for Dust Bowl migrants. Here's how:

1. Setting the Scene:

• The excerpt might begin by describing the idyllic image of California often portrayed in the media or the migrants' expectations based on hearsay. This creates a stark contrast with the harsh realities that follow.

2. Introducing Reality:

• The author then shifts the focus to the actual experiences of the migrants. This could involve:
  • Vivid descriptions of the harsh living and working conditions, including poverty, lack of sanitation, and discrimination.
  • Quotes or anecdotes from the migrants themselves, showcasing their struggles and dashed hopes.
  • Statistics or data to paint a broader picture of the widespread hardships faced by the migrant population.

3. Breaking the Myth:

• By juxtaposing the initial image with the harsh reality, the author debunks the myth of California as a promised land for Dust Bowl migrants. This highlights the broken promises and unmet expectations that contributed to their suffering.

4. Building an Emotional Connection:

• The structure allows the author to elicit sympathy and empathy for the migrants. By showcasing their struggles, the author encourages the reader to see their plight from their perspective.

Full Answer Section

5. Implied Argument:

• The overall structure serves as an implicit argument against the romanticized image of California and the hardships faced by the migrants due to misleading portrayals and unfulfilled promises.

Additional Points:

• The use of chronological order might be employed to highlight the migrants' journey and the gradual disillusionment they faced.
• Contrasting language and imagery can be used to emphasize the difference between the promised and the real California.

By strategically structuring the excerpt, the author effectively conveys the harsh realities of life in California for Dust Bowl migrants, challenging the idealized narrative and urging the reader to acknowledge their plight.