Purpose of essay is to determine which of the two writers has presented the stronger argument
- shocking data in introduction is a plus
- Example of thesis: Coates' case for reparations is stronger than Frum's rejection of reparations for the following reasons: Coates' claims are… and his argument is founded on principles that establish the foundation of American democracy. On the other hand, Frum's argument is flawed because….. this is example, ad long as it takes position on their arguments
- summary of Coates' argument- summarize atleast 3 major claims from his essay and look for evidence to support claim
- Summary of Frum's rebuttal. Summarize Frum's rebuttal to Coates. 3 major claims with evidence which From makes against Coates' argument.
- Argument for stronger position. Which of the two writers present stronger argument and why. make sure to give specific reasons for decision
- recommendations for convincing others. think of reasons why opponents may not agree with you. Cultural, political, and economic reasons that prevent others from agreeing with you. Some media misinform people about what reparations entail.. Most importantly make others see why they should agree with you.