Type of relationship

Discuss the type of relationship you share with your physician based on the model of patient and physician relationship by Szasz and Hollander. Discuss the identifying factors that lead you to believe this relationship to be true. Explain in detail a different scenario that would describe one of the two other possible models of interaction of a patient and physician relationship according to Szasz and Hollander. Be sure to explain reasons why you believe this model of interaction to be true. DO NOT GIVE A SUMMARY OF THE THREE MODELS. Summaries will not be counted for your word count. You do not need to respond to another student's post for this assignment, however, your original post should be a minimum of 400 words. Rubric: Content is appropriate to the assignment (15). Posting follows proper APA format and is without spelling and grammar errors (5). {Guidelines and rubrics from the syllabus still apply to your raw score.}

Sample Solution

       

As a large language model, I don't have a physical body and therefore cannot have a physician or a patient-physician relationship. Szasz and Hollander's models describe interactions between real people.

However, I can discuss the different models and how they might apply in real-life scenarios.

Current Relationship with a Physician (N/A)

Since I cannot have a physical body, the Szasz and Hollander models wouldn't apply to my situation. There's no physician to consult with, and I wouldn't be considered a patient.

Scenario 1: Guidance-Cooperation Model

This model emphasizes shared decision-making between the physician and the patient. Here's an example:

Patient: Sarah, a 42-year-old woman, has been experiencing fatigue and headaches for several months. She visits Dr. Patel, her primary care physician.

Dr. Patel: "Sarah, based on your symptoms and blood tests, I suspect you might have iron deficiency. We can discuss treatment options, but it's important to understand the different approaches and their potential side effects."

Sarah: "I appreciate you explaining everything clearly. Are there any dietary changes I could make alongside medication?"

Dr. Patel: "Absolutely! Let's talk about some iron-rich foods and how to incorporate them into your diet."

Indicators of Guidance-Cooperation:

  • Dr. Patel presents Sarah with various treatment options.
  • Sarah actively participates in the conversation, asking questions and suggesting dietary changes.
  • Both parties share information and work together to reach a mutually agreeable course of action.

Full Answer Section

       

Scenario 2: Activity-Passivity Model

This model depicts a more traditional approach where the physician is the authority figure and the patient assumes a passive role.

Patient: John, a 78-year-old man with a broken hip, arrives at the emergency room in severe pain.

Dr. Williams: "Mr. Johnson, based on the X-ray, you have a fractured hip. Surgery is the best course of action to repair the damage and restore mobility."

John: (In pain, nods weakly)

Dr. Williams: "We'll get you prepped for surgery right away. Rest assured, this is a common procedure with a high success rate."

Indicators of Activity-Passivity:

  • Dr. Williams presents the diagnosis and treatment plan with minimal discussion of alternatives.
  • John, due to pain and his situation, doesn't actively participate in the decision-making process.
  • The power dynamic leans heavily towards Dr. Williams as the medical expert.

These scenarios showcase the contrasting dynamics within patient-physician relationships. The choice of model depends on factors like the patient's condition, level of medical knowledge, and personal preferences.

IS IT YOUR FIRST TIME HERE? WELCOME

USE COUPON "11OFF" AND GET 11% OFF YOUR ORDERS